【書評】「史実を世界に発信する会」 茂木弘道

< 書 評 >




評者:タダシ・ハマ(日本語訳:「史実を世界に発信する会」 )












令和3年11月15日 「史実を世界に発信する会」 茂木弘道



<Book Review>

The Un-Civil War: Shattering the Historical Myths.

By Leonard M. Scruggs (Universal Media, 2011)

Reviewed by: Tadashi Hama


   The most destructive conflict in American history, in terms of both lives lost and property destroyed, the so-called American Civil War, has been poorly represented in modern American history classes and, concurrently, everywhere else.  Author Leonard Scruggs points out that the American “Civil War” was “not really a civil war”.  

A key misconception of the so-called Civil War is that President Abraham Lincoln waged war against the South to end African slavery. Scruggs points out that ending slavery was not the most critical issue at the time—ending slavery was important only to extremist abolitionists. The greater issue that loomed over America before the first shots were fired was the Republican’s ham-handed imposition of their political and economic will onto the Southern states.

  For President Lincoln, Scruggs points out, freed blacks were to be deported, either sent back to Africa or to colonize Central America; Lincoln did not see any hope of blacks and whites living together. Northern states had long-standing laws against interracial marriage. As a member of the state legislature, Lincoln “fully approved” of prohibiting blacks entry into “free state” Illinois. 

As Karl Marx stated: “The war between the North and South is a tariff war. The war is further, not for any principle, does not touch the question of slavery, and in fact turns on the Northern lust for power,” the key factor for the war was not the question of slavery.

Thinking broadly, one should wonder why it is that demonstrable falsehoods are passed off as genuine history and why unpleasant but true history is diligently ignored.

In the end, based on a distorted view of history, ostensibly intelligent Americans meekly yield to the political and economic demands of supposedly victimized ethnic minorities.

We should take heed that this thinking is not unique to Americans.  





MOTEKI Hiromichi, Acting Chairman

for KASE Hideaki, Chairman

Society for the Dissemination of Historical Fact

Phone: 03-3519-4366

Fax: 03-3519-4367



Note: Japanese names are rendered surname first in accordance with Japanese custom.